Element evidence rubric Four criteria, each scored 1-4. Total: 16 points. Use with the lesson template and assignments. Accuracy 4: All element identities, particle counts, quantities and units are correct; distinguishes atomic mass from mass number. 3: Main claims are correct; one minor label or unit error does not change the conclusion. 2: Several correct facts, but a significant identity, particle-count or quantity error affects the explanation. 1: Major factual errors or missing data prevent a valid explanation. Evidence 4: Uses at least two relevant values or observations, names the source, and states an applicable limitation. 3: Uses relevant evidence and identifies its source; limitation is general or incomplete. 2: Includes some data, but relevance, source or context is unclear. 1: Gives unsupported claims or no usable evidence. Reasoning 4: Connects evidence to the claim with an appropriate scientific explanation and addresses an exception or alternative. 3: Gives a sensible connection between evidence and claim, with limited discussion of alternatives. 2: Restates the data or gives a partially supported connection. 1: Provides no connection, or reasoning contradicts the evidence. Communication 4: Organizes the response clearly with readable labels, units and appropriate vocabulary; another learner can follow it. 3: Mostly clear and organized, with minor ambiguity. 2: Meaning can be recovered, but missing labels or unclear structure interrupt understanding. 1: Response is incomplete or difficult to interpret. Feedback record Accuracy ___ /4 Evidence ___ /4 Reasoning ___ /4 Communication ___ /4 Total ___ /16. Strength: _____________________________________ Next step: _________________________________________________ An omitted criterion can be recorded as 0; explain this expectation before assigning the task. Adapt response formats without lowering the scientific goal. Sources and limitations: https://elementexplore.com/sources.html Classroom copying and adaptation permitted. Suggested levels, not formal alignment.